Ordained Priest | Years | Name | Current Title |
| Most Senior |
| 7 Mar 1954 |
| Bishop Sydney Anicetus Charles | Bishop Emeritus of Saint George’s in Grenada, Grenada |
| 7 Dec 1954 |
| Bishop Benedict Singh | Bishop Emeritus of Georgetown, Guyana |
| 10 Jul 1955 |
| Bishop Malcolm Patrick Galt, C.S.Sp. | Bishop Emeritus of Bridgetown, Barbados |
| 21 Dec 1955 |
| Archbishop Maurice Rigobert Marie-Sainte | Archbishop Emeritus of Fort-de-France (e Saint Pierre), Martinique |
| 8 Apr 1956 |
| Archbishop Kelvin Edward Felix | Archbishop Emeritus of Castries, Saint Lucia |
| 26 May 1956 |
| Adam Joseph Cardinal Maida | Archbishop Emeritus of Detroit, Michigan, USA |
| 31 May 1958 |
| Theodore Edgar Cardinal McCarrick | Archbishop Emeritus of Washington, District of Columbia, USA |
| 3 Apr 1959 |
| Bishop Osmond Peter Martin | Bishop Emeritus of Belize City-Belmopan, Belize |
| 20 Dec 1959 |
| Archbishop Gilbert Marie Michel Méranville | Archbishop of Fort-de-France (e Saint Pierre), Martinique |
| 2 Feb 1960 |
| Archbishop Edgerton Roland Clarke | Archbishop Emeritus of Kingston in Jamaica |
| 11 Jun 1960 |
| Archbishop Eugenio Sbarbaro | Apostolic Nuncio Emeritus to Serbia |
| 14 Aug 1960 |
| Bishop Aloysius Ferdinandus Zichem, C.SS.R. | Bishop Emeritus of Paramaribo, Suriname |
| Most Junior |
| 17 Apr 1993 |
| Bishop Christopher John Glancy, C.S.V. | Auxiliary Bishop of Belize City-Belmopan, Belize |
| 23 Jun 1991 |
| Bishop Burchell Alexander McPherson | Bishop of Montego Bay, Jamaica |
| 19 Mar 1991 |
| Bishop Charles Jason Gordon | Bishop of Bridgetown, Barbados |
| 28 Jun 1987 |
| Bishop Vincent Matthew Darius, O.P. | Bishop of Saint George’s in Grenada, Grenada |
| 29 Sep 1985 |
| Bishop Kenneth David Oswin Richards | Bishop of Saint John’s-Basseterre, Virgin Islands (British) |
| 28 Jul 1985 |
| Bishop Gabriel Malzaire | Bishop of Roseau, Dominica |
| 7 Jul 1985 |
| Bishop Francis Dean Alleyne, O.S.B. | Bishop of Georgetown, Guyana |
| 25 May 1985 |
| Bishop Wilhelmus Adrianus Josephus Maria de Bekker | Bishop of Paramaribo, Suriname |
| 5 Sep 1982 |
| Archbishop Léon Kalenga Badikebele | Apostolic Nuncio to El Salvador |
| 15 Aug 1980 |
| Archbishop Patrick Christopher Pinder | Archbishop of Nassau, Bahamas |
| 15 Jun 1980 |
| Archbishop Nicolas Girasoli | Apostolic Nuncio to Antigua and Barbuda |
| 18 Sep 1976 |
| Bishop Louis Albert Joseph Roger Sankalé | Bishop of Nice, France |